Dissocial Personality Disorder
PhenomenonMigrated Candidate
Plain explanation
A person with dissocial personality disorder shows a core pattern of callousness and lack of empathy, unable to genuinely comprehend how their cruel or careless behaviour affects other people. Any apology they offer tends to be superficial, real remorse is absent, and they show little capacity to learn from experience or from punishment. A low tolerance for boredom often drives thrill-seeking behaviour such as substance misuse, gambling, or promiscuity, and while some are superficially charming and able to form relationships, these tend to be short-lived, while others present as more obviously cold and hard, sometimes taking pleasure in hurting those close to them.
Classic definition note
This has traditionally been distinguished from ordinary criminality by emphasising that most violent or law-breaking people do not have this personality disorder, and that the diagnosis rests specifically on the underlying pattern of callousness and remorselessness rather than on criminal behaviour itself.
Recognition features
- Callousness and a genuine inability to comprehend the impact of one's cruel or careless behaviour on others
- Superficial apologies, absent remorse, and little learning from experience or punishment
- A low boredom threshold driving thrill-seeking behaviour such as substance misuse, gambling, and promiscuity
- A pattern of short-lived relationships, sometimes with a history of serial marriages or cohabitations ending in infidelity or violence, alongside superficial charm in some and obvious coldness or cruelty in others
- A childhood history often including conduct disorder, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, truancy, cruelty to animals, fighting, and substance misuse
- Characteristic use of the defence mechanisms of projection (blaming others for one's own behaviour) and rationalisation (claiming justification for it)
- A veneer of civility that can assist in employment and relationships until it drops, at which point it tends to alienate others and lead to major social dysfunction
Distinguishing features
- Must be distinguished from the secondary criminal behaviour caused by alcohol or drug misuse alone, which is absent when the substance misuse is absent; this is especially difficult when the substance misuse began in adolescence, since it may then be impossible to establish which came first
- Must be distinguished from risk-taking and aggression occurring only during a manic episode, where the history should clarify that the pattern is confined to that episode rather than lifelong
- Must be distinguished from personality and behaviour change following certain brain lesions, where a clear history of the relevant trauma or injury clarifies the diagnosis
- Must be distinguished from adolescent antisocial behaviour arising from a deprived background, which may resolve with maturation into a well-adjusted adult, and should not be labelled as this personality disorder without a longer history into adult life
- Differs from borderline personality disorder, with which it can be confused, especially in women, in that borderline personality disorder lacks the core features of callousness and remorselessness
- Most violent people do not have dissocial personality disorder, so criminality alone is not synonymous with, or sufficient evidence for, this diagnosis
Eliciting notes
- Take a detailed developmental history, particularly of childhood conduct problems, since these commonly precede the adult pattern
- Ask directly about remorse following harm caused to others, and listen for genuine understanding of the other person's perspective as opposed to a superficial or self-serving account
- Be aware that the person's own history may be unreliable, given a recognised tendency toward dishonesty, and seek corroboration from other sources where possible
- Explore relationship history for a pattern of short duration and conflictual endings, and ask about substance misuse, gambling, and other thrill-seeking behaviour
- Assess low mood carefully: where present, establish whether it is a response to thwarted plans, which tends to resolve quickly, rather than a sustained depressive episode
Common misconceptions
- That dissocial personality disorder is simply another name for criminality; most people who behave violently or unlawfully do not have this personality disorder, and the diagnosis rests on an underlying pattern of callousness and remorselessness rather than on offending itself
- That antisocial behaviour beginning in adolescence always predicts this personality disorder in adulthood; many such adolescents, particularly from deprived backgrounds, mature into well-functioning adults and should not be given this diagnosis prematurely
- That superficial charm rules out this diagnosis; some people with dissocial personality disorder are notably charming, at least until that veneer drops
Associated conditions
- Antisocial Personality Disorder
Example illustration
A 33-year-old man dismisses his third failed marriage by explaining that his wife 'brought it on herself by nagging him,' shows no visible reaction on learning that his gambling debts have left his children without heating for a week, and describes a charming first impression that colleagues later reconsider once they discover he had been quietly falsifying his expense claims for over a year.