Distortion of Recall

PhenomenonMigrated Candidate

Plain explanation

Distortion of recall is the category of paramnesia in which the actual content of a remembered event is falsified — altered, invented outright, or borrowed from elsewhere and misattributed — rather than the general feeling of familiarity being what is affected. It covers a wide range of specific named patterns, from the everyday colouring of memory by current mood, through to elaborate, organically driven confabulation.

Classic definition note

This has traditionally been treated as one of the two broad divisions of paramnesia, the other being distortion of recognition, with the dividing line being whether it is the content of a memory that is wrong (recall) or the felt sense of familiarity surrounding an experience that is wrong (recognition).

Recognition features

  • The specific content of a remembered event is altered, invented, or drawn from elsewhere and wrongly attributed to personal experience
  • Several distinct named patterns exist beneath this heading, differing mainly in cause, degree of elaboration, and whether an organic process is involved
  • Can range from subtle, mood-driven colouring of past events to florid invention of entire episodes
  • Suggestibility is a recurring theme across several of these patterns, and is worth assessing where any of them is suspected

Distinguishing features

  • Differs from distortion of recognition, in which the content of a memory may be accurate but the felt sense of familiarity attached to an experience is what is disturbed
  • The specific named patterns beneath this heading are distinguished chiefly by their underlying mechanism: mood-driven colouring, outright invention, painful material substituted for other painful material, organically driven gap-filling, or conscious versus unconscious embellishment
  • Suggestibility plays a recognised role across most of these specific patterns and is a useful thread linking them

Eliciting notes

  • Where a distorted account is suspected, compare it where possible against collateral information or documented fact
  • Assess the person's general level of suggestibility, since this is relevant across several of the specific patterns grouped under this heading
  • Consider the presence or absence of an organic cause, since this substantially narrows which specific pattern is most likely

Common misconceptions

  • That distortion of recall always implies deliberate dishonesty; several of the specific patterns grouped here occur entirely without conscious intent to deceive
  • That these patterns are rare or exotic; milder forms, particularly mood-driven distortion of past experience, are common and can be found in ordinary clinical presentations of depression

Example illustration

A 39-year-old man recalling his time at university describes it, during a depressive episode, as an unbroken run of academic failure and social isolation, a portrait his old friends and his own preserved university records both firmly contradict, showing a period that was, in fact, largely successful and socially full.