Distortion of Recognition

PhenomenonMigrated Candidate

Plain explanation

Distortion of recognition is the category of paramnesia in which the felt sense of familiarity attached to a person, place, or event goes wrong, rather than the actual content of a remembered event being falsified. A situation may feel wrongly familiar, a genuinely familiar situation may feel wrongly unfamiliar, or, more strikingly, a familiar person may be wrongly recognised as someone else entirely.

Classic definition note

This has traditionally been treated as one of the two broad divisions of paramnesia, alongside distortion of recall, with the dividing line being that here it is specifically the feeling of familiarity, or the identity attached to a person, that is disturbed, rather than the content of what is remembered.

Recognition features

  • The felt sense of familiarity or unfamiliarity attached to a current experience or a familiar person is disturbed
  • Can range from brief, subjectively striking experiences occurring in healthy people, to persistent and elaborated misidentification occurring in psychotic or organic illness
  • The mismatch is specifically between the feeling of recognition and the objective reality of the situation, rather than between what actually happened and what is remembered
  • May affect places and events (as in déjà vu and its relatives) or specific people (as in false reconnaissance)

Distinguishing features

  • Differs from distortion of recall in that the content of an experience may be entirely accurately perceived; it is the accompanying feeling of familiarity, or the identity attributed to a person, that is disturbed
  • Brief experiences such as déjà vu occur in the general population and are not, on their own, evidence of illness, unlike the more persistent and elaborated misidentification seen in false reconnaissance and Capgras syndrome
  • The specific target of the distortion (a place or event, versus a specific person's identity) distinguishes the different named patterns within this category

Eliciting notes

  • Ask directly about brief experiences of false familiarity or false unfamiliarity, since these are common and easily normalised or overlooked unless specifically asked about
  • Where misidentification of a specific person is suspected, explore exactly what the person believes and how firmly, since this ranges from a passing, brief impression to a fixed delusional conviction
  • Consider an organic cause, particularly temporal lobe epilepsy, when experiences of this kind are frequent, prolonged, or unusually intense

Common misconceptions

  • That any distortion of recognition indicates serious illness; brief, occasional experiences such as déjà vu are extremely common in healthy people
  • That distortion of recognition always involves a false belief in the delusional sense; some of these experiences are purely subjective feelings without any accompanying false conviction

Example illustration

Walking into a shop she has genuinely never visited before, a 28-year-old woman is struck by an overwhelming, specific feeling that she has been in this exact place before, right down to noticing where the till was going to be before she saw it, a fleeting but vivid sensation she finds hard to shake even once she is certain, on reflection, that it cannot be true.