Drivelling Thinking
PhenomenonMigrated Candidate
Plain explanation
Drivelling thinking is a form of formal thought disorder in which a person begins with a complete outline of a complex thought, including all its necessary parts, but loses the organisation needed to keep those parts properly arranged, so that everything becomes jumbled together. The person often remains critically aware that something about their thinking is not right, even though they cannot restore the proper order.
Classic definition note
This has traditionally been described as a breakdown specifically in the normal 'organisation' of thought — the property by which the different elements of a complex thought are ordinarily kept related to each other without blending together — distinguishing it from a breakdown in constancy (as in transitory thinking) or continuity (as in desultory thinking).
Recognition features
- The overall content and constituent parts of a complex thought appear to be present, but their organisation and relationship to one another is muddled
- The person often retains a critical attitude toward their own thinking, sensing that something is not right even without being able to fix it
- Meaning shifts and becomes obscured as the internal relationships between the parts of the thought break down
- Differs from a simple lack of ideas: the raw material of the thought is present, but its arrangement has failed
Distinguishing features
- Differs from transitory thinking in that grammatical and syntactical structure is less disrupted; the problem lies in the arrangement of the thought's content rather than sentence structure itself
- Differs from desultory thinking in that the intrusions here are not simple, isolated extra ideas but a muddling of the necessary components of one single complex thought
- Retained critical insight into the difficulty is a relatively distinctive feature compared with some other forms of formal thought disorder
Eliciting notes
- Give the person a moderately complex topic to describe and note whether the individual components of their answer are all present but arranged in a confused, jumbled order
- Ask whether they feel their own thinking is 'muddled' or unclear, since retained critical awareness of the difficulty is a notable feature here
- Compare with transitory thinking by checking whether grammar and sentence structure remain broadly intact even as meaning becomes confused, which is more typical of drivelling
Common misconceptions
- That drivelling thinking reflects a lack of ideas or knowledge; the constituent parts of the thought are present, but their organisation has broken down
- That the person is unaware anything is wrong; a critical attitude toward the confusion is often retained, which can itself be a source of distress
Example illustration
Asked to describe how to make a cup of tea, a 44-year-old man lists the kettle, the cup, the milk, and the teabag, but arranges them into a jumbled, circular account that keeps looping back on itself without ever settling into a clear sequence, pausing afterward to say, with evident frustration, that he knows it didn't come out right but cannot see how to say it properly.