Hysterical Twilight State

PhenomenonMigrated Candidate

Plain explanation

A hysterical twilight state is a restriction of consciousness arising from unconscious motives rather than an organic process, occurring when a person under severe psychological conflict becomes so preoccupied that they lose full awareness of their environment, retaining only a hazy sense of recent events. This can extend to a temporary 'forgetting' of personal identity and one's entire past, functioning, in effect, as an unconscious escape from otherwise overwhelming difficulties; wandering states of this kind, with accompanying memory loss, have also been called fugues, though not all fugues arise this way.

Classic definition note

This has traditionally been noted as genuinely difficult to assess in terms of how much of the underlying motivation is truly unconscious, since in some cases the person appears to be at least partly, deliberately running away from their troubles, and the pattern has also been described as occurring more readily in those with a previous head injury and concussion, possibly because they are already familiar with the pattern of amnesia from that earlier experience.

Recognition features

  • A restriction of consciousness arising in the context of severe, unresolved psychological conflict, rather than an identifiable organic cause
  • Only a hazy awareness of recent events, sometimes extending to a temporary loss of awareness of personal identity and one's whole past
  • May present as a wandering, fugue-like state, of variable duration, sometimes lasting an extremely long time
  • The degree to which the underlying motivation is genuinely unconscious versus at least partly deliberate can be genuinely difficult to determine on assessment

Distinguishing features

  • Differs from an organic twilight state, such as one caused by epilepsy, in arising from unconscious psychological motives rather than an identifiable organic process, though the ICD-10 recognises the diagnostic overlap and difficulty here directly
  • Differs from deliberate malingering in that the unconscious element is considered genuine, though the book acknowledges this can be very difficult to establish with confidence in any individual case
  • Overlaps with dissociative fugue and dissociative amnesia, since a wandering hysterical twilight state with loss of personal identity is essentially the same broad phenomenon described from a different angle

Eliciting notes

  • Take a careful history of the psychological circumstances and conflicts preceding the onset of the episode, since a severe, unresolved stressor is a characteristic precipitant
  • Assess memory for personal identity and recent history carefully, noting the specific pattern and extent of what has been 'forgotten'
  • Ask about any previous history of head injury or concussion, since this has been noted as a factor that may make this presentation more likely, possibly through prior familiarity with an amnesic pattern

Common misconceptions

  • That a hysterical twilight state is simply a deliberate act of running away or evading responsibility; while this possibility must be considered, the underlying process is understood as substantially, though not always entirely, unconscious
  • That fugue states are always hysterical in origin; the book explicitly notes that some fugue-like wandering, with memory loss, occurs in depression rather than through unconscious psychological motives

Associated conditions

  • Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

Example illustration

Weeks after the sudden collapse of his business and marriage within the same month, a 47-year-old man is found several hundred miles from home, unable to recall his own name or how he got there, having apparently supported himself with casual labour for over a week under a name that is not his own, with no memory of the period once his identity is eventually established.