"He describes it all so calmly, that's what struck me most"

2 of 8 steps revealed

Fictional training case. A deterministic, staged teaching case — description before diagnosis. Information is revealed one stage at a time. Not a real patient and not a diagnosis quiz.

auditory-hallucination thought-insertion affect-blunting

Vignette

A 26-year-old man is interviewed for the first time following a two-month history of social withdrawal. In a flat, unvarying tone and with minimal facial expression throughout, he explains: "There's a voice, a man's voice, that talks about me — not to me, just talks about what I'm doing, out loud, like commentary. It's not in my head, it's just there, like you talking now." He goes on, in the same flat manner: "And sometimes a thought will just appear that isn't mine. I know it's not mine — someone else has put it there. I can't explain it any better than that." Throughout the interview, including when describing these two distressing experiences, his face and voice show almost no variation, and he does not appear to react even when asked directly how frightening this all is: "I don't know. It's just how it is, I suppose," he says, with the same flat expression as before.

Identify

The voice providing a running commentary on his actions is best identified as:

Phenomenological answer: An auditory hallucination

Discriminating feature: He describes it as having the same perceptual quality as a real external voice — "like you talking now" — with no real source producing it, which is the defining feature of a true auditory hallucination.

Identify

The experience of a thought appearing that he knows is not his own is best identified as:

Phenomenological answer: Thought insertion

Discriminating feature: He is confident the thought was placed there by someone else and recognises it as foreign, rather than experiencing it as his own unwanted thought — the defining feature of thought insertion.

Reveal next step →

Provenance

Class B · tier T1 · lifecycle migrated_candidate