“Nothing feels real” — separating depersonalization from derealization
Fictional training scenario. A deterministic, authored teaching exercise — not a real patient and not a diagnostic tool. The aim is to establish the phenomenology cleanly, not to pick a “right answer”.
Patient: Nothing feels real any more. I can’t explain it.
closed thin You: Do you feel detached?
Patient: Yeah, detached. That’s the word.
Information gained: Gets a label for the feeling.
Information lost: You supply the word ‘detached’; the patient’s own description is thin.
A serviceable closed question, but it borrows your vocabulary rather than eliciting the lived quality.
leading contaminated You: The world around you looks fake and unreal, right?
Patient: I suppose the world does seem a bit off, now you say it.
Information lost: You suggest derealization; the patient drifts toward your framing.
By naming only the surroundings you bias the answer toward derealization. The locus axis is contaminated.
Contaminated: locus
You want to check whether reality testing is intact (‘as-if’, not delusional). What would you ask?
Pick the question you would actually ask. There is no marked “correct” option — each choice has consequences you will see.