“Thoughts that aren’t mine” — clarifying a possible passivity experience

Fictional training scenario. A deterministic, authored teaching exercise — not a real patient and not a diagnostic tool. The aim is to establish the phenomenology cleanly, not to pick a “right answer”.

  1. Patient: I know people are putting thoughts into my head. It’s not right.

  2. closed thin You: Are these thoughts your own thoughts — yes or no?

    Patient: No. Not mine.

    Information gained: You get a bare answer on ownership, but no description of the quality of the experience.

    Information lost: A yes/no closes down the account; you learn the conclusion but not the phenomenon.

    A closed question can confirm a point but yields thin phenomenology. Ownership is addressed but only superficially — partially clarified.

Next you want to know whether the patient feels they are making the thought happen. What would you ask?

Pick the question you would actually ask. There is no marked “correct” option — each choice has consequences you will see.

Start over