“Thoughts that aren’t mine” — clarifying a possible passivity experience
Fictional training scenario. A deterministic, authored teaching exercise — not a real patient and not a diagnostic tool. The aim is to establish the phenomenology cleanly, not to pick a “right answer”.
Patient: I know people are putting thoughts into my head. It’s not right.
leading contaminated You: So you’re experiencing thought insertion, then?
Patient: …I suppose so, if that’s what you call it.
Information lost: The patient adopts your technical term rather than describing their experience.
A leading, jargon-laden question. The agreement reflects suggestion, not the patient’s own experience — the report of ownership is now contaminated and cannot be relied on.
Contaminated: ownership
leading contaminated You: The government is controlling your thoughts, aren’t they?
Patient: …maybe. You think so too?
Information lost: You supply both the agent and the explanation; the patient may simply agree. Rapport and reliability both drop.
This invents the source for the patient and models certainty. Any answer is contaminated for both agency and source.
Contaminated: agency, source
You want to know whether the patient can resist or dismiss the thoughts. What would you ask?
Pick the question you would actually ask. There is no marked “correct” option — each choice has consequences you will see.