Discriminate · Forced Grasping vs Automatic Obedience
2 of 2 steps
Deliberate practice, not a test. Items are organised by target (phenomenon or defence) and by evidence axis. Nothing here is scored, graded or recorded — you weigh the prompt, then reveal the worked phenomenological reasoning. Fictional teaching material.
Forced Grasping Automatic Obedience
Prompt
Facet: Discrimination · cognitive operation: DISTINGUISH
A patient's behaviour does not match a given instruction. Before revealing the answer, decide what distinguishes forced grasping from automatic obedience.
Worked reasoning (reasoning, not a score)
Ask whether the patient's behaviour is going against the instruction given, or complying with it regardless of consequences. Forced grasping differs from automatic obedience in involving persistence of an action against an explicit instruction, rather than compliance with an instruction regardless of its consequences: the patient continues to grasp despite being told not to. Automatic obedience, by contrast, involves carrying out every instruction given, regardless of its content or consequences, even when doing so is uncomfortable or repeatedly painful, with the patient failing to adjust their behaviour despite direct, repeated unpleasant experience of following the instruction. Whether the behaviour opposes an instruction or indiscriminately follows one, is the key distinguishing feature.
References
- Casey, P. & Kelly, B. (2019). Fish's Clinical Psychopathology, 4th ed. Ch. 8, 'Motor Disorders'.
Provenance: class B · tier T1 · migrated_candidate