Discriminate · Mutism vs Pure Word-Dumbness
2 of 2 steps
Deliberate practice, not a test. Items are organised by target (phenomenon or defence) and by evidence axis. Nothing here is scored, graded or recorded — you weigh the prompt, then reveal the worked phenomenological reasoning. Fictional teaching material.
Prompt
Facet: Discrimination · cognitive operation: DISTINGUISH
A patient has stopped speaking entirely. Before revealing the answer, decide what distinguishes general mutism from the specific pattern of pure word-dumbness.
Worked reasoning (reasoning, not a score)
Ask specifically whether reading and writing are consistently and cleanly preserved alongside the absence of speech. Mutism is the broad, general term for a complete loss of speech, arising from many possible causes and presentations, in which writing may or may not be preserved depending on the underlying cause. Pure word-dumbness is a specific, named sub-type distinguished precisely by the clean, consistent preservation of reading and writing alongside a total absence of speech — a clear dissociation between spoken and written language that is not guaranteed in mutism more broadly and is the key distinguishing feature of this particular pattern.
References
- Casey, P. & Kelly, B. (2019). Fish's Clinical Psychopathology, 4th ed. Ch. 4, 'Disorders of Thought and Speech'.
Provenance: class B · tier T1 · migrated_candidate