Recognise · Pure Word-Dumbness
2 of 2 steps
Deliberate practice, not a test. Items are organised by target (phenomenon or defence) and by evidence axis. Nothing here is scored, graded or recorded — you weigh the prompt, then reveal the worked phenomenological reasoning. Fictional teaching material.
Prompt
Facet: Recognition · cognitive operation: RECOGNIZE
A patient is entirely unable to speak, spontaneously or on request, yet writes fluent, grammatically correct, and entirely appropriate answers to every question asked of him in writing. What is this?
Weigh each candidate description — nothing is selected or marked:
- Pure word-dumbness
- Mutism
- Expressive aphasia
- Receptive aphasia
Worked reasoning (reasoning, not a score)
Phenomenologically appropriate description: Pure word-dumbness
This is pure word-dumbness: a total inability to produce spoken words, with reading and writing remaining entirely intact, exactly as described. It is not expressive aphasia, since pure word-dumbness differs from expressive aphasia, in which written language is also typically affected to some degree, whereas here it remains essentially normal. It is not mutism generally, in which writing may or may not be preserved, whereas here it is specifically and consistently preserved. And it is not receptive aphasia, in which comprehension itself is impaired, whereas here the patient clearly understands and appropriately answers every question in writing.
References
- Casey, P. & Kelly, B. (2019). Fish's Clinical Psychopathology, 4th ed. Ch. 4, 'Disorders of Thought and Speech'.
Provenance: class B · tier T1 · migrated_candidate