Recognise · Receptive Aphasia
2 of 2 steps
Deliberate practice, not a test. Items are organised by target (phenomenon or defence) and by evidence axis. Nothing here is scored, graded or recorded — you weigh the prompt, then reveal the worked phenomenological reasoning. Fictional teaching material.
Prompt
Facet: Recognition · cognitive operation: RECOGNIZE
A patient speaks fluently and without apparent effort, but the words he produces are often unrelated to any question asked, and he shows no sign of understanding spoken or written instructions given to him. What is this?
Weigh each candidate description — nothing is selected or marked:
- Formal thought disorder
- Mutism
- Expressive aphasia
- Receptive aphasia
Worked reasoning (reasoning, not a score)
Phenomenologically appropriate description: Receptive aphasia
This is receptive aphasia: the chief difficulty lies in understanding language, whether spoken or written, with speech production itself relatively preserved in its mechanical aspects, exactly as described. It is not expressive aphasia, since receptive aphasia differs from expressive aphasia in that comprehension, rather than production, is the chief difficulty — here, fluent speech is produced but understanding is impaired, the reverse of expressive aphasia's pattern. It is not mutism, since speech is clearly present and fluent here, whereas mutism is a complete absence of spoken output. And it is not a formal thought disorder more broadly, which concerns the structure and organisation of thinking rather than a specific, lesion-linked failure of language comprehension.
References
- Casey, P. & Kelly, B. (2019). Fish's Clinical Psychopathology, 4th ed. Ch. 4, 'Disorders of Thought and Speech'.
Provenance: class B · tier T1 · migrated_candidate