Running Commentary Voices
Domain: perception
Practise this phenomenon along each evidence axis (facet) independently.
Deliberate practice, not a test. Items are organised by target (phenomenon or defence) and by evidence axis. Nothing here is scored, graded or recorded — you weigh the prompt, then reveal the worked phenomenological reasoning. Fictional teaching material.
Recognition (RECOGNIZE)
- Recognise · Running Commentary Voices A man reports hearing two voices, speaking to each other about him in the third person, describing his actions as he performs them in real time: 'he's picking up the cup now... he's putting it down again.' What is this?
Description (GENERALIZE)
- Explain · Running Commentary Voices Explain why the specific, real-time link between the voice's content and the patient's ongoing behaviour is what defines running commentary voices, rather than simply the voice's third-person phrasing.
Elicitation (ELICIT)
- Elicit · Running Commentary Voices You are assessing a patient for auditory hallucinations and want to establish whether running commentary voices are present. Before revealing the answer, decide what you would ask.
Discrimination (DISTINGUISH)
- Discriminate · Running Commentary Voices vs Thought Echo A patient describes hearing a voice that seems tightly linked to what they are doing or thinking. Before revealing the answer, decide what single question distinguishes running commentary voices from thought echo.
Application (SEQUENCE A CLINICAL ENQUIRY)
- Apply · Running Commentary Voices A woman describes a single voice that speaks directly to her, saying 'you are worthless, you should stop trying', appearing at moments unrelated to what she happens to be doing at the time. Before revealing the answer: is this running commentary voices?
Documentation (DOCUMENT)
There are no governed recognise/explain/elicit/discriminate/apply items for the Documentation axis. Documentation is trained and evaluated by the MSE Builder (S5) and MSE Quality Checker (S6), not by a practice-item bank. The Practice engine surfaces this axis as a cross-link to those modules and never fabricates practice items for it.
Integration (SYNTHESIZE)
There are no governed practice items for the Integration axis. Integration is trained by the Case Lab (S9) and OSCE Lab (S10) through staged whole-encounter work. The Practice engine surfaces this axis as a cross-link to those modules and never fabricates practice items for it.